Top-rated Domestic Assault and Battery Lawyer in Bristol, Norfolk, & Plymouth Counties, Massachusetts
Domestic assault and battery, encompassing violence against a household member, police officer, or with a dangerous weapon, is a serious offense with significant legal ramifications in Massachusetts. These charges can carry not only jail time and fines, but also restraining orders, mandatory counseling, and a lasting impact on your personal life, employment prospects, and even custody arrangements.
Our multi-faceted approach starts with a thorough scene investigation to uncover crucial evidence overlooked by law enforcement.
Based on the gathered evidence, we can aggressively challenge the credibility of accusers and witnesses through detailed background checks and cross-examination strategies.
Alternatively, we can negotiate with prosecutors for charge reductions or dismissals. In some cases, we can explore the possibility of sealing or expunging your record to minimize the long-term impact of the charges.
Get in touch with the Law Office of Michael P Carroll PC today for more information.
How We Can Help
- Challenging Probable Cause: We thoroughly examine the circumstances that led to your arrest. We will look for potential flaws in police procedure or probable cause for the charges. This process involves contesting the legality of search warrants, witness testimonies, or the initial detainment.
- Mitigating Factors: Our lawyers explore all mitigating factors that could lessen the charges or sentencing. This might include self-defense arguments, mental health evaluations, evidence of prior abuse by the alleged victim, or intoxication that significantly impaired your judgment.
- Pre-Trial Negotiations: Depending on the severity of the charges and other factors, we can engage the prosecution in plea bargaining discussions. We will aim for a lesser charge, reduced jail time, or participation in pretrial diversion programs (if applicable) in exchange for completing counseling or community service.
- Court Representation: We have a proven track record in presenting compelling defense arguments, cross-examining witnesses, and contesting the prosecution's evidence.
- Firearm Rights Protection: For cases involving alleged dangerous weapons, we consult with ballistics experts and materials scientists to contest the classification of objects as "dangerous weapons" under Massachusetts law. We work with you to explore all possible legal recourses.
Legal Consequences of Domestic Assault and Battery Charges
Assault and Battery on a Household Member
Under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 265, Section 13M, this offense is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 2.5 years in the house of correction, a fine of up to $5,000, or both. A conviction also mandates the completion of a certified batterer's intervention program. Subsequent offenses may be charged as felonies, carrying increased penalties.
Assault and Battery on a Police Officer
According to G.L. c. 265, section 13D, this charge is a felony offense. A conviction can result in a minimum 90-day jail sentence or up to 2.5 years in a house of correction, plus a fine of $5,000. The severity of the sentence often depends on the extent of injury to the officer and the defendant's prior record.
Assault with a Dangerous Weapon
This felony offense, defined in M.G.L. c. 265, section 15B, carries a maximum sentence of 5 years in state prison or 2.5 years in jail, along with a fine of up to $1,000. If the weapon is a firearm, the minimum sentence is 18 months. The court considers factors such as the nature of the weapon and the defendant's intent when determining the sentence.
CLIENT TESTIMONIALS
Protection for Victims of Domestic Assault and Battery
If you are a victim of domestic assault and battery, it is crucial to seek legal protection immediately. The Law Office of Michael P. Carroll PC is committed to helping victims of domestic violence get the protection they deserve and hold perpetrators accountable for their actions. We assist victims by:
Obtaining Restraining Orders
We can help you file for a restraining order (also known as a protection order) to keep the perpetrator away from you, your children, and your home. This is a critical step in preventing further harm and ensuring your safety.
Criminal Prosecution
As a victim, you have the right to press charges and seek justice. Our team will help you navigate the criminal justice process, ensuring that the offender is held accountable for their actions.
Victim Support Services
We understand the emotional and psychological toll that domestic violence can take. We can connect you with counseling and support services to help you heal and move forward with your life.
Family Law Matters
In cases involving children, domestic violence charges can affect custody and visitation arrangements. We will fight to protect your rights and ensure that your children are placed in a safe environment.
Understanding Domestic Assault and Battery
Domestic assault and battery are criminal offenses that involve violent behavior or the threat of violence against a person with whom the offender has an intimate or familial relationship. These charges are considered serious due to the potential for physical harm and the emotional impact they have on families. The criminal justice system treats domestic assault and battery with heightened sensitivity, which is why it is essential to have an experienced attorney to protect your interests.
- Assault: Assault is the intentional act of causing another person to fear imminent harm or violence. This could involve threats, gestures, or actions that make the victim believe they are in immediate danger.
- Battery: Battery involves the actual physical contact or harm to another person without their consent. It could range from hitting, slapping, or pushing to more severe forms of physical violence.
When these offenses occur in a domestic setting—such as between spouses, partners, or family members—they are charged as domestic assault and battery. The legal process for handling domestic violence cases is different from other assault and battery cases, as they often involve added complexities such as protective orders, child custody issues, and heightened emotional stakes.
Let Us Help You Build a Strong Defense
We are well aware of the lasting impact these serious charges can have on your life. Our goal is to protect your rights, freedom, and future. For clients with no prior record, we aggressively pursue pre-trial diversion programs to avoid formal charges. Our lead attorney, Michael P. Carroll, will be your representative in court, challenging the prosecution's case by confidently cross-examining the prosecution's witnesses, potentially exposing inconsistencies or weaknesses in their testimonies.
Get in touch with our office today for more information.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What exactly constitutes “domestic assault and battery” under Massachusetts law — and how is it different from general assault?
Domestic assault & battery typically means that the alleged victim is someone with whom the defendant shares a domestic relationship (spouse, former spouse, cohabitant, dating partner, family member). The elements mirror general assault & battery (intentional or reckless physical harm or offensive touching), but the domestic nature can bring additional consequences (restraining orders, mandatory training, more severe bail conditions). Understanding that “domestic” is a statutory enhancement is vital: it triggers distinct procedures, higher stakes, and sometimes mandatory penalties even for first offenses.
If I’m accused of domestic assault but it was self-defense, can that be a valid defense?
Yes — self-defense (or defense of another) is one of the primary defenses in assault cases, including domestic ones. But the burden is delicate: you must show you reasonably believed you faced imminent harm and that your force was proportionate. In domestic settings, courts also scrutinize whether there was a safe alternative (e.g. walking away) or whether you provoked the confrontation. Our firm will closely examine all evidence, witness statements, and physical indicators to build a credible self‑defense narrative.
How soon should I contact an attorney after being arrested or even before charges?
As soon as possible. In many domestic assault cases, evidence (photos, medical records, messages, witness statements) begins to degrade immediately. The police report, initial statements, and the setting of bail or release conditions are set early. Having legal counsel early means you can challenge investigations, guide what you say (or don’t say) to law enforcement, file motions in a timely fashion, or even avoid charging via pre‑arraignment steps. Delay can weaken your defense significantly.
Can allegations of domestic assault be dropped or dismissed before going to trial?
Yes — under certain conditions. If the evidence is weak (no credible witness, no injuries, inconsistent statements, procedural violations), motions to dismiss or suppress evidence (e.g. illegal searches or coerced confessions) may succeed. Prosecutors sometimes drop or downgrade charges after a strong defense presentation. In other cases, negotiated resolutions like diversion programs, plea to a lesser offense, or agreement to counseling may avoid a full trial. But this depends heavily on facts, prior record, and the judge/prosecutor in that county.
Will a domestic assault conviction affect my criminal record, employment, or custody rights?
Absolutely. A conviction goes on your criminal record permanently (unless sealed or expunged under narrow circumstances). That can impact job prospects, professional licensing, housing, immigration status, and more. In family law cases (divorce, child custody), opposing parties or judges often use such convictions against you. In some domestic assault cases, mandatory counseling or batterers’ intervention programs may be required. We always consider collateral consequences and strategize to minimize long‑term damage.
How does a restraining order (209A) play into my case, and can I challenge it?
Restraining orders (Abuse Prevention Orders under Mass. Gen. L. c. 209A) often accompany domestic assault cases. Even if you’re never convicted, the order can impose significant restrictions (no contact, stay-away zones, custody restrictions). Yes — these orders can be contested at a hearing, often needing strong cross‑examination, evidence, and legal argument. Our firm prepares for both the civil restraining order process and the criminal defense, coordinating strategy so that one doesn’t undermine the other.
What are the hidden risks if I choose to represent myself (pro se) in a domestic assault case?
Going pro se is extremely risky. A layperson may not know procedural deadlines (motions, discovery), evidence rules (what’s admissible or suppressed), and local courtroom practices. You might inadvertently waive rights, make admissions, or fail to object to damaging testimony. The defense attorney knows how to negotiate with prosecutors, understand sentencing options, and manage jury perception. In domestic assault cases, reputation and emotional context matter; unskilled representation can worsen outcomes.
Can evidence like texts, social media messages, or recording devices help or hurt my case?
Yes — digital evidence is increasingly central. They can be powerful proof of threats, admissions, or behavior. But their authenticity, chain of custody, and legality matter. If law enforcement or the opposing side obtains evidence improperly (without valid warrants or violating rights), it may be suppressed. Also, context is critical: an out-of-context message can be misconstrued. We always scrutinize digital evidence, hire forensic experts, and challenge improper admissions.
What is the typical timeline for a domestic assault case through the Massachusetts courts?
It varies, often from several months to over a year. Key phases include arrest, arraignment, discovery, pretrial motions (suppression, dismissal), possible plea negotiations, trial, and sentencing if convicted. Emergency restraining orders or hearings may add parallel proceedings. Delays can happen due to court backlog, continuances, or new evidence. We keep clients informed of expected deadlines, file motions proactively, and push for timely resolution while preserving defense rights.
What factors influence whether a jury trial or bench (judge) trial is better?
Each has pros & cons. A jury brings peer judgment and can be more sympathetic to personal narratives; but juries may be swayed by emotion or biases. A judge may focus more closely on legal issues, evidence admissibility, and consistency. In domestic cases, allegations of violence may provoke strong emotional reactions in jurors. We analyze whether a judge or jury is likelier to be fair in your county, evaluate the specifics of the case, and advise which forum gives you the best chance.